Sawbuck vs. Decker Pack Saddle

Some differences between a Sawbuck Pack Saddle and Decker Pack Saddle are obvious. A Sawbuck has crossbucks made usually of oak or metal that form an X shape at the top of the saddle tree, while a Decker has metal arches.

When comparing a Sawbuck vs. decker pack saddle, one key distinction is that a Sawbuck does not traditionally use a pack saddle cover known as a “half-breed” (or “1/2 Breed”), while a Decker style does. Lastly, most Sawbucks are “double rigged,” whereas a Decker Pack Saddle is traditionally “single rigged.”

Learn more about the specific differences and how to choose the right option for your situation in this pack saddle comparison guide.

Crossbuck or Arches: The X-shaped crossbucks on a Sawbuck pack saddle are great for packing with panniers, and top loads and have been used in packing for millennia.   The metal arches, either traditional or modified, are specific to the Decker-style pack saddle. These provide versatility to either use panniers, or the ability to tie a manty load using ropes to secure it to the pack saddle. The metal arches also give the Decker rigidity and strength, which could protect the pack saddle in the event of a wreck.

If you're packing soft panniers or canvas manties, Decker pack saddle arches offer more secure tie-down points. They excel on backcountry trips when loads need to be customized or re-tied frequently. On the other hand, Sawbucks are simpler to use and ideal for riders who stick to traditional pannier setups.

Pack Saddle Cover: Traditionally on Decker pack saddles only, this pack saddle cover known as a half-breed, has two main functions. Because the half-breed contains a wooden board running along either side, the load that you are packing is more evenly distributed across the length of your stock animal reducing its burden.

This also gives you the ability to pack a larger load on a single animal. The other function is that it simply covers the pack saddle, reducing the amount of dust and debris that can and will inevitably be encountered on the trail, which can protect both the animal and your equipment.

The built-in weight distribution makes Decker saddles with half-breeds especially useful for long hauls or when carrying irregularly shaped cargo. The cover also extends the life of your gear by minimizing trail dust and friction on the saddle frame.

Double or Single Rigged: A Sawbuck pack saddle is double rigged, has 2 rings on either side of the saddle, and requires a double cinch with 4 latigos. This rigging would be locked into a fixed position with a Sawbuck pack saddle, meaning that the cinch used cannot be adjusted forward or backward on the animal. 

Generally speaking, a Decker pack saddle is single-rigged with a single ring on either side of the pack saddle, and requires a “decker” cinch with 2 latigos. A single-rigged pack saddle gives you versatility to adjust the position of your cinch from full rigged (the front most position) to a “center fire” position (the center of the pack saddle), and anywhere in between. 

Decker saddles provide improved fit flexibility for different animals and terrain. On steep trails, you can slide the cinch to reduce pressure and enhance comfort. Sawbucks are more fixed in structure, which can be an advantage if you’re new to horse packing and want a no-fuss setup.

For riders hauling elk quarters, camp tools, or backcountry gear, Decker saddles provide the modular flexibility needed for oddly shaped items. But a Sawbuck could be the faster, more intuitive choice if you’re guiding shorter trips or hauling similar-sized panniers.

Choosing the Right Pack Saddle for Your Trail, Built to Last

We make our pack saddles using the finest leather, Hermann Oak harness leather. We double stitch all of the stress points, and hand rivet using solid copper rivets to ensure strength and longevity of our equipment. Our Decker pack saddle trees are designed in the O.P. Robinett style, which is the gold standard in the industry. Our wood Sawbucks are made with solid oak to ensure their durability. Whether you are more comfortable with a Sawbuck style or Decker style pack saddle, Outfitters Supply has you covered. 

If you're debating the Sawbuck vs. Decker pack saddle for your next ride, start by evaluating your route, load type, and experience level. Decker saddles offer more technical performance and modularity, while Sawbucks provide durability and simplicity, ideal for straightforward trail work.

Trail conditions also matter. In rocky or remote areas, the ability to adjust and customize a Decker setup can make all the difference. On smoother, well-traveled routes, the traditional Sawbuck saddle is often quicker and more intuitive to set up.

Don’t overlook storage needs when comparing horse packing options. Decker saddles pair especially well with manty loads and oversized gear. The Sawbuck is often a better match for symmetrical loads and fitted saddlebags.

For whichever style you choose, a proper saddle fit is essential. An ill-fitting saddle— Decker or Sawbuck—can cause rubbing, pressure points, and long-term discomfort for your animal. When in doubt, consult our gear guides or reach out for expert advice.

Both pack saddle styles have loyal followings. The key is matching the right gear to your packing goals, animal type, and trail demands. Quality materials, smart design, and proper fit should guide every decision.

Not sure which pack saddle is right for your next trip? Browse both styles and find your perfect fit. And if you’re looking for additional gear? Explore our full lineup of saddlebags and accessories. Outfitters Supply is built by and for people who know the trail.